Decoy Effect
Adding a third option that is clearly worse than one choice but similar in price makes that choice look more attractive.
Key takeaways
- The options around a choice change how valuable it seems.
- A deliberately inferior option can steer users toward a target option.
- Use comparisons to clarify value, not to trick people.
Origin
Joel Huber, John Payne and Christopher Puto described the asymmetric dominance effect in 1982. Dan Ariely popularised it with an example of a magazine offering web-only, print-only and print-plus-web subscriptions where the print-only option existed mainly to make the bundle look like a bargain.
How to apply it
- Review how each option in a set affects the perceived value of the others.
- Design plans so that the recommended option offers clear value.
- Use comparison tables to make trade-offs transparent.
- Test different plan sets to understand how choices shift.
- Ensure every option is genuinely useful to someone.
How Science of Apps uses this law
2 checks in every investigation rely on Decoy Effect, for example: “Is the comparison honest: free vs paid, distinct styles, no fake urgency?”
Get your product investigated